Sherlock's Baker St. Pub & Grill

Been coming here for years, but this was my 1st time popping in, since COVID. Happy Hour drinks and prices are still awesome, but it's just not the same without the live music side. Not sure if that side opens up later in the day or not. If not, I hope that changes soon.

Sherlock's is just a great time with food. It's definitely more of a 30s to 50s crowd and the music is so loud it just goes through you. I wish it would bring the music down just a little bit but that could be because I'm getting at that age that the music just annoys me. It is fun to take friends there and just hang out and spend a lazy afternoon.

At the very most, this restaurant would be a 5/10. While the servers are friendly and talkative, the food is mediocre at best. The drinks were delicious although lacking in alcoholic taste as we had the funky monkey, the boozeberry punch, and the watermelon cucumber lemonade.

The food was quite disappointing in flavor and pricing. While I understand the times are changing with inflation, I do not believe the portions match the price whatsoever. Definitely the place to come get drunk as I can imagine relatable characters becoming regular patrons of the establishment. Do not waste your money or time on the food in this place.

A local referred this place. Good service, good food, good location.

Music was a bit too loud for my taste.

But I could see that folks enjoyed returning to this location.

I hate that I forgot the name of the young lady who served us. You could see that she was busy. But very personable, not just with us, but with other patrons as well.

It was good to see and experience.

This place will always be a favorite due to their affordable drinks, great food and fun atmosphere. They have several dart boards, a pool table and live music on the weekends. If you like the pub scene, this is definitely a great place to check out.

Logan is great. Super friendly and accommodating! Appreciated him super much!

But whoever the manager/older man is was less than friendly. Upset about his preference for football. Changed the sound with minutes left and then was upset when the customers asked for it to be turned back. And by customers I don’t mean just us. It was slow and the two tables inside both agreed. So that was kind of annoying. It wouldn’t have even been worthy of a mention had he been polite like oh I’m sorry I didn’t realize both tables were watching the same thing and turned it back without making it seem like it was such a big deal. But the bad attitude needed addressed. 😕

Oh and the Buffalo dip could be bigger.😂

There's better places in Addison to check out. Highly recommend not stopping here. Visited late Wednesday night for some birthday drinks for a friend. We sat at the main bar on the first floor when a cockroach crawled across the bar top. As I freaked out, the bartender, Mackenzie, calmly reached over, killed it with a napkin, and walked away. I would assume by her calmness, this was NOT the first roach she's had to kill in this bar. Where there is 1 roach, there are SEVERAL in hiding. This is a direct reflection of the cleanliness of the bar, which is simply, not clean. After this incident, I did not finish my drink, paid my tab of 1 drink and swiftly left. The small food portions at ridiculous prices (don't even get me started on the 8 individual nachos for $14) and dirty bars are enough to keep me from ever going back.

This place sucks all around. Our waiter was either high or drunk. He was so inattentive- we were forgotten about on several occasions. He frequently forgot things we ordered and we had to request them again. The restrooms were not clean. The food wasn't worth the price and the cocktails were very subpar for the price as well. I highly do not recommend and won't be back. There are plenty of places within walking distance that are far better quality.